Birth/baptism conflict

Completed discussions and topics. All topics are locked on archive. Please contact a forum moderator if you'd like a thread reactivated.

Moderators: grangers14, admin, Northern Lass

Locked
Davholsea
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Nov 09, 2012 3:34 pm
Primary Surname Interests: Cunningham
Primary Geographical Research Areas: Liverpool

Birth/baptism conflict

Post by Davholsea »

Hi there.
I have a birth cert and a baptism entry for my GG g'dad which appear to be the same person but differ on the DOB.
Given that the baptism pre-dates the cert - what's the explanation?

Birth: 1/1/1881
Name: Peter Cunningham
Mother: Jane Cunningham
Father: Thomas Cunningham
Address: 3 Burnet St Liverpool

Baptism: 25/12/1880
Birth: 17/12/1880
Name: Peter Cunningham
Mother: Jane Cunningham
Father: Thomas Cunningham
Address: 3 Burnet St Liverpool

I'd appreciate any help or suggestions?
User avatar
linell
Posts: 5054
Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2008 10:50 am
Primary Surname Interests: Stringer Worton Haynes Mason Reading Pratt Willetts Hackett Brown Darby
Primary Geographical Research Areas: Black Country
Location: Stafford

Re: Birth/baptism conflict

Post by linell »

Hi I would think that the Jan 1881 date is when his birth was actually registered.

Linell
peterd
Posts: 15669
Joined: Mon Sep 29, 2008 12:33 pm
Primary Surname Interests: Dorricott. Watterson. Evans. Bracegirdle. Quinn. Mcloughlin
Primary Geographical Research Areas: Shropshire. Cheshire. Lancashire. Black Country. Co Durham
Location: co durham
Contact:

Re: Birth/baptism conflict

Post by peterd »

as linell points out there was and still is an allowance of days between birth and registration, plus as his birth was late dec poss to late to include in that qrt registration anyway
A person should have an opinion on everything, It becomes tact whether you reveal that opinion or not.

http://www.deneview.co.uk/
User avatar
MarkCDodd
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:55 pm
Primary Surname Interests: Homer, Dodd, Murphy, Cutler, Ford
Primary Geographical Research Areas: Shropshire, Staffordshire, Worcestershire, Yorkshire

Re: Birth/baptism conflict

Post by MarkCDodd »

Baptism always wins out over whatever is on the birth certificate.

Baptism dates are sequential in the parish register and entered by the Church Warden/Clerk on the day of the event.

Birthdays on the GRO certificate are supplied many days or weeks after the birth and are not checked.

Sometimes the birth on the certificate is falsified so that the child appears to be born under wedlock.
Black Holes happen when God divides by zero.
jo.
Posts: 19
Joined: Sun Sep 23, 2012 8:18 am
Primary Surname Interests: Thomas, Parsons and Creedy
Primary Geographical Research Areas: Taunton, Bridgwater and South Wales.

Re: Birth/baptism conflict

Post by jo. »

It may also be because they hadn't registered the baby within the first 6 weeks, which since registration Act 1837 was brought in, if you didn't you would face an hefty fine/imprisonment which still stands today.

The church had no powers of fining anybody, so you'll more likely to be truthful to the priest/vicar...
Locked

Return to “Archived General Discussion”