Genealogy Forum UK

I tracked Ann Egginton as daughter of Abel Egginton

http://bcconnections.tribalpages.com/tr ... =367952732

and location and Census all looked correct but then noticed tree on Ancestry with totally different line from marriage to a John Egginton in 1851 by an Ann Peasnall and then Marriage to Isaac Watson in 1857
I think Ancestry Tree is wrong as Ann Peasnall was born in Northamptonshire or Oldbury Warks. not Oldbury Worcs. as Ann who married Isaac Watson was

WATSONIsaacEGGINGTONAnnDudley, St ThomasDudley Register Office204/016/206 1857

Ancestry Tree looks like using marriage of Samuel Egginton to Ellen Brown as foundation for using John Egginton line rather than Abel Egginton line

http://bcconnections.tribalpages.com/tr ... =462812796

Marriage 15/7/1877
St.John The Evangelist , Kates Hill, Dudley
Samuel Eggington 21 b. Brickmaker father John Egginton (dec.) Furnace Man
Ellen Brown 19 sp. no father detailed

Only one Samuel Egginton born West Bromwich at that time so link to Isaac Watson is correct but either my version of line from Abel Egginton is correct and John Egginton on marriage cert is false or Ancestry tree is correct but locations for birth of Ann Watson (nee Egginton or Peasnall) on census are incorrect.

who were the witnesses on marriage ?

James Grosvenor and Elizabeth Ann Walls ? were witnesses
and although Ellen Brown's father not noted occupation looks like Cordwainer

Checked again and occupation of Ellen Brown's father is Carpenter

1861. Tividale.
Thomas Brown 50. Carpenter. Leicestershire.
Mary Brown 42. Northamptonshire.
Frances Brown 16. Dau.
Victoria Brown 13. Dau.
Henry Brown 11. Son.
Maryann Brown 8. Dau.
Eliza Brown 6. Dau.
Elin Brown 3. Dau.
Frederick Brown 1. Son.

Others born Marston, Northamptonshire.

1871. Tividale.
Thomas Brown 60. Widow. Carpenter. Foston, Leicestershire.
Mary A Brown 16. Dau. House keeper.
Ellen Brown 14. Dau.
Frederic Brown 12. Son.
Elizabeth Brown 4. Dau. Dudley, Worcestershire.

Others born Mayton, Northamptonshire.

Thanks Jimmy , That ties up with Census record and birth cert for Ellen brown

I will post this marriage for look up and it may resolve who father of Ann Egginton was

WATSONIsaacEGGINGTONAnnDudley, St ThomasDudley Register Office204/016/206 1857

Ok thanks to Rf for marriage info I am adding to Bcc now

and disconnecting Ann from Abel father on marriage is James Eggington bricklayer not Abel

added here..
http://bcconnections.tribalpages.com/tr ... =664463666

1851. Workhouse Lane, West Bromwich.
John Eggington. Unm.
Age: 42. Brickmaker.
Estimated Birth Year: abt 1809.
Where born: W Bromch, Staffordshire
Civil parish: West Bromwich.
Ecclesiastical parish: All Saints.
County/Island: Staffordshire.

Is Ann an Egginton,

The only marriage I can see for a john Egginton is,

West Midlands Marriage indexes for the years: 1851.
EGGINTON John. PEASNALL Ann. Tipton, St Martin (Pepper Box).

John Egginton.
Groom's Birth Date: 1820.
Groom's Age: 31.
Bride's Name: Ann Peasnall.
Bride's Birth Date: 1829.
Bride's Age: 22.
Marriage Date: 1851.
Marriage Place: St. Martin, Tipton, Stafford.
Groom's Father's Name: George Egginton.
Bride's Father's Name: James Peasnall.
Indexing Project (Batch) Number: M16744-8.
System Origin: England-VR.
Source Film Number: 1526189.
Reference Number: 2:3Q4ZMZ9.

1851. Blisworth, Northamptonshire.
James Peasnall 50. Brick maker. Blisworth, Northamptonshire.
Jane Peasnall 46. Lace maker. Blisworth, Northamptonshire.
Ann Peasnall 21. Dau. Lace maker. Oldbury, Warwickshire.
Joseph Peasnall 13. Son. Blisworth, Northamptonshire.
Charlotte Peasnall 9. Son. Blisworth, Northamptonshire.
Sarah J Peasnall 6. Dau. Blisworth, Northamptonshire.
Mary Knight 75. Blisworth, Northamptonshire.

Should James Egginton be James Peasnall on this marriage, considering Ann is a widow.

6th April 1857 St Thomas Dudley.
Isaac Watson full widower labourer Dudley Richard Watson labourer.
Ann Eggington full widow Dudley James Eggington brickmaker.
banns.
X both.
Wit - X Henry Simkins X Hannah Nightingale.

Ann Egginton was Ann Peasnall

1851 Census West Side Low Town West Bromwich Staffs,
William Peasnall Head 28 Blast Furnce Labourer born Blisworth Northants.
Eliza Peasnall wife 21 born Halesowen Worcs.
John Egginton brother.in.law (wid) 30 Blast Furnace Fitter bprn Oldbury Worcs.
George Peasnall nephew 9 Blast Furnace Fitter born Oldbury Worcs.
Esther Peasnall sister 16 Lace Maker born Blisworth Northants.

Can trace Peasnall family and will add

Thanks to everone for sorting out I will add rest of info

Still something funny as Ann Egginton is shown as widow on marriage details
and father James Egginton
and father of Samuel Egginton is shown as John Egginton on marriage cert.

It wouldn't be the first time the vicar as put wrong names, been at the altar wine,