More Nanny State rubbish!
Moderators: Northern Lass, admin, peterd
- MarkCDodd
- Posts: 4157
- Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:55 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Homer, Dodd, Murphy, Cutler, Ford
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Shropshire, Staffordshire, Worcestershire, Yorkshire
More Nanny State rubbish!
I live in the suburb of Boronia in the city of Knox in the state of Victoria.
Victoria has a reputation of being the "Nanny" state.
It appears that Victorians have no sense and for our own good all actions will be dictated by a never ending set of state laws and local bylaws.
My wife and I were going to buy and operate a child care center but the big binders of rules and regulations handed to me put me off.
All this rubbish about gender neutral toys and the evasion of Christian days of importance and a set list of approved books to be read etc etc etc.
That was all political correct rubbish more than 20 years ago and it has got worse since.
Now my local council has come up with this doozy.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/knox-council-bans-the-sharing-of-home-made-cakes-also-bans-egg-cartons-and-toilet-rolls/story-fnglekhp-1226585158793
I rang and spoke to one of the councilors this morning and asked him to provide me a single documented case where a home made cake has resulted in harm to children.
He said he would get back to me. I don't think so!
Asthma and other childhood ailments are at an all time high because we have wrapped them in cotton wool.
We do not let them get dirty or take risks.
Playground equipment has been changed to remove the dangerous elements and many school grounds have little or any exposed earth.
I used to be proud of the bath rings I would leave after a good day of playing outside!
I used to play Santa for several charities and hospitals for many years.
Than a few years ago they gave me a list of "regulations" that dictated the exact words I should use in response to particular wishes made.
I had to ensure that both hands were visible in every photograph taken.
Of course they could not provide me once single example of a Santa being convicted of groping a child anywhere in the world.
I wasn't going to be turned into a robot so have not played Santa for five years.
I wish I could throttle the idiots who come up with this rubbish.
Many rules are put in place without a tiny bit of evidence that a problem needs correcting.
Enough I say!
Victoria has a reputation of being the "Nanny" state.
It appears that Victorians have no sense and for our own good all actions will be dictated by a never ending set of state laws and local bylaws.
My wife and I were going to buy and operate a child care center but the big binders of rules and regulations handed to me put me off.
All this rubbish about gender neutral toys and the evasion of Christian days of importance and a set list of approved books to be read etc etc etc.
That was all political correct rubbish more than 20 years ago and it has got worse since.
Now my local council has come up with this doozy.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/knox-council-bans-the-sharing-of-home-made-cakes-also-bans-egg-cartons-and-toilet-rolls/story-fnglekhp-1226585158793
I rang and spoke to one of the councilors this morning and asked him to provide me a single documented case where a home made cake has resulted in harm to children.
He said he would get back to me. I don't think so!
Asthma and other childhood ailments are at an all time high because we have wrapped them in cotton wool.
We do not let them get dirty or take risks.
Playground equipment has been changed to remove the dangerous elements and many school grounds have little or any exposed earth.
I used to be proud of the bath rings I would leave after a good day of playing outside!
I used to play Santa for several charities and hospitals for many years.
Than a few years ago they gave me a list of "regulations" that dictated the exact words I should use in response to particular wishes made.
I had to ensure that both hands were visible in every photograph taken.
Of course they could not provide me once single example of a Santa being convicted of groping a child anywhere in the world.
I wasn't going to be turned into a robot so have not played Santa for five years.
I wish I could throttle the idiots who come up with this rubbish.
Many rules are put in place without a tiny bit of evidence that a problem needs correcting.
Enough I say!
Black Holes happen when God divides by zero.
- Antie Em
- Posts: 4309
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:17 am
- Primary Surname Interests: Salt, Jones, Humphries, Riley, Barklam/Bartlam, Shilvock, Guest
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Halesowen, Dudley, Clent, Tipton, Rowley Regis, Kingswinford, Wall Heath
- Contact:
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
Bringing in home made cakes was outlawed in my grandchildren's nursery ten years ago because of the concern that some very young children attending nursery may suffer from serious food allergies.
There's no place like home ......
- dudleytaylor
- Posts: 1538
- Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2012 12:29 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Badley ,Taylor,Cadman,Hazelwood Hughes Spiers
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Dudley Oldbury Warley Langley
- Location: Living in Worcestershire,Paternal Family from Dudley,Maternal family from Oldbury
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
Being a retired Nursery Nurse , I do understand your concerns . My daughter is a working nursery nurse ,and she has told me that things are changing constantly . Now to make nursery care cheaper for parents the government is thinking about changing the ratio between adults and children. Which will be detrimental to the children . Taking children out for the day will be less likely to happen. With parents permission we would take children to the park ,all this will stop because there will not be enough adults to care for the children. I am afraid that with all the paperwork and rules , children's nursery's will change dramatically in the next few years .
It's easy to stand with the crowd . It takes courage to stand alone
- Antie Em
- Posts: 4309
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:17 am
- Primary Surname Interests: Salt, Jones, Humphries, Riley, Barklam/Bartlam, Shilvock, Guest
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Halesowen, Dudley, Clent, Tipton, Rowley Regis, Kingswinford, Wall Heath
- Contact:
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
I am actually in favour of not allowing children to eat what wasn't prepared in the nursery or sent in by the parents of the child. The nursery my grandchildren attended had a locker for each child for anything that was sent in by their parents and given to them at certain times in the day. All their meals were prepared on site, giving special consideration for any allergies. When they had a "party" day we brought in party food, but it all had to be covered in the manufacturer's wrapping. Even when we have the children's friends staying over or coming for tea, we always ask the parents for any dietary requirements.
There's no place like home ......
- dudleytaylor
- Posts: 1538
- Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2012 12:29 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Badley ,Taylor,Cadman,Hazelwood Hughes Spiers
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Dudley Oldbury Warley Langley
- Location: Living in Worcestershire,Paternal Family from Dudley,Maternal family from Oldbury
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
The nursery I worked for had its own kitchen, and cook. All meals were prepared on the day .Children had their own pegs for coats. Clean aprons were used for all meals.We had our own washing machines ,and drier. We catered from 4 months to school age .All dietary needs were catered for.
It's easy to stand with the crowd . It takes courage to stand alone
- snoopysue
- Posts: 3947
- Joined: Thu May 20, 2010 7:12 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Fellows Jinks Wearing Jeavons Jensen Barker Skidmore Beardmore Woodall
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Staffordshire, Worcestershire, Warwickshire, Denmark
- Location: Denmark
- Contact:
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
I agree a little with Mark, children today are wrapped up in cottonwool; there are several studies that show that, for example, kids that grew up on farms have less allergies than kids that grew up in "cleaner" environments.
That being said, once a child has an allergy, then we have to be careful, especially with food allergies, as they are so potentially dangerous.
That being said, once a child has an allergy, then we have to be careful, especially with food allergies, as they are so potentially dangerous.
Snoopysue
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority.
- dudleytaylor
- Posts: 1538
- Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2012 12:29 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Badley ,Taylor,Cadman,Hazelwood Hughes Spiers
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Dudley Oldbury Warley Langley
- Location: Living in Worcestershire,Paternal Family from Dudley,Maternal family from Oldbury
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
I also agree with Mark, I also think government's go to far.It doesn't hurt children to get a little dirty ,and build wonderful constructions out of toilet rolls and cereal boxes. When I was a child I played in the garden making mud pies and pulling weeds out in piles ,gathering stones ,selling them in my pretending shop. 

It's easy to stand with the crowd . It takes courage to stand alone
-
- Posts: 15671
- Joined: Mon Sep 29, 2008 12:33 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Dorricott. Watterson. Evans. Bracegirdle. Quinn. Mcloughlin
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Shropshire. Cheshire. Lancashire. Black Country. Co Durham
- Location: co durham
- Contact:
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
dudleytaylor wrote:I also agree with Mark, I also think government's go to far.It doesn't hurt children to get a little dirty ,and build wonderful constructions out of toilet rolls and cereal boxes. When I was a child I played in the garden making mud pies and pulling weeds out in piles ,gathering stones ,selling them in my pretending shop.
and came in for something to eat some bread and jam with hands as black as the mud


A person should have an opinion on everything, It becomes tact whether you reveal that opinion or not.
http://www.deneview.co.uk/
http://www.deneview.co.uk/
- Rob
- Posts: 5822
- Joined: Fri Oct 03, 2008 4:01 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Williams,Beard,Young,Ruston
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Black Country,Knowle,Dorridge,Lapal,Kings Norton.
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
I grew up playing over "The Blue Billy".A vast mound created from chemical waste from ICI and Albright and Wilsons.Red ochre,purple ochre.It would be all over you.
- dudleytaylor
- Posts: 1538
- Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2012 12:29 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Badley ,Taylor,Cadman,Hazelwood Hughes Spiers
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Dudley Oldbury Warley Langley
- Location: Living in Worcestershire,Paternal Family from Dudley,Maternal family from Oldbury
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
That's quite right Pete, I never washed my hands . We only had cold water tap ,we had a tin bath hung up in the kitchen . When we had a bath mom would fill the boiler , light the gas underneath ,and we would wait ages for it to get hot. Every morning we would have a bowl of warm soapy water by the living room fire ,and mom would wash me from top to toe. We didn't have a bathroom till we moved ,when I was fourteen. Our house was condemned ,as were many in Handsworth. Now there is a very large school built where I was born . The tree that my uncle planted in my granddads garden, in the same road as us ,now stands proudly in the school grounds. Oh what fun i had as a child.
It's easy to stand with the crowd . It takes courage to stand alone
- dudleytaylor
- Posts: 1538
- Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2012 12:29 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Badley ,Taylor,Cadman,Hazelwood Hughes Spiers
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Dudley Oldbury Warley Langley
- Location: Living in Worcestershire,Paternal Family from Dudley,Maternal family from Oldbury
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
Rob wrote:I grew up playing over "The Blue Billy".A vast mound created from chemical waste from ICI and Albright and Wilsons.Red ochre,purple ochre.It would be all over you.
My uncle Beric worked for Albright and Wilsons. As a little girl ,my mom would take me on the Midland Red bus to Oldbury and Langley , and i remember seeing ,what i thought was mountains of coal slack, but it might have been what you refer too. I also remember seeing the the last of the tramlines . My mom came from Langley , and we would go there a lot to see family. .
It's easy to stand with the crowd . It takes courage to stand alone
- SRD
- Posts: 2445
- Joined: Tue Jan 04, 2011 5:34 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Hillman
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Sussex
- Location: Wiltshire
- Contact:
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
And yet recorded life expectancy goes up and up, I wonder what it was that was killing all those people, especially children, all those years ago?
Currently investigating the Hillmans of Sussex.
- Antie Em
- Posts: 4309
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:17 am
- Primary Surname Interests: Salt, Jones, Humphries, Riley, Barklam/Bartlam, Shilvock, Guest
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Halesowen, Dudley, Clent, Tipton, Rowley Regis, Kingswinford, Wall Heath
- Contact:
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
I worked for the local NHS Primary Care Trust about 10 years ago and while I was there we compiled statistics for the whole country for people with asthma, especially children. Sandwell (which includes Oldbury and Langley) had the highest incidence of asthma in the whole of the country. This wasn't for a 100 years ago - this was only about 10 years ago.
There's no place like home ......
- mikleed
- Posts: 814
- Joined: Sat Jul 11, 2009 7:45 pm
- Primary Surname Interests: Leedham,Poole,Hall,Smart,Goode, Field.
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Rowley Regis, Halesowen, Leicestershire Nova Scotia Australia
- Location: Black Country
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
A lot of revived complaints that we have again now, were imported back to this green and pleasant land......including TB.!!!
Mike
Mike
Englands Green and Pleasant Land.
- Antie Em
- Posts: 4309
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:17 am
- Primary Surname Interests: Salt, Jones, Humphries, Riley, Barklam/Bartlam, Shilvock, Guest
- Primary Geographical Research Areas: Halesowen, Dudley, Clent, Tipton, Rowley Regis, Kingswinford, Wall Heath
- Contact:
Re: More Nanny State rubbish!
Oldbury has never been green or pleasant Mike.
Quote from the History of Oldbury : "Industry continued to develop, with chemical manufacture starting in 1837 to supply the glass works at Smethwick, followed by phosphorus extraction in 1850, tar distillation and plastics. As coal mining and iron extraction declined, brick making spread, exploiting the layer of Etruria marl below Oldbury. Iron and steel manufacture expanded with edge tools, railway carriages, boilers and tubes being sent around the world.
This industrial expansion destroyed much of the green countryside that surrounded Oldbury in 1800, leaving spoil heaps, marl holes, quarries, pits and pollution throughout the area, and a legacy of reclaiming the land throughout the twentieth century. What was not destroyed was built over, and now little green space remains, save the parks and open spaces bequeathed by industrialist benefactors."
I live in Langley, which is now a really nice little area of Oldbury, next to Langley Park which was bequeathed by Messrs Albright and Wilson. I remember visiting Langley when I was in my teens and we had to close all doors and windows when the "yellow fog" was escaping from Albright's.
Quote from the History of Oldbury : "Industry continued to develop, with chemical manufacture starting in 1837 to supply the glass works at Smethwick, followed by phosphorus extraction in 1850, tar distillation and plastics. As coal mining and iron extraction declined, brick making spread, exploiting the layer of Etruria marl below Oldbury. Iron and steel manufacture expanded with edge tools, railway carriages, boilers and tubes being sent around the world.
This industrial expansion destroyed much of the green countryside that surrounded Oldbury in 1800, leaving spoil heaps, marl holes, quarries, pits and pollution throughout the area, and a legacy of reclaiming the land throughout the twentieth century. What was not destroyed was built over, and now little green space remains, save the parks and open spaces bequeathed by industrialist benefactors."
I live in Langley, which is now a really nice little area of Oldbury, next to Langley Park which was bequeathed by Messrs Albright and Wilson. I remember visiting Langley when I was in my teens and we had to close all doors and windows when the "yellow fog" was escaping from Albright's.
There's no place like home ......