Genealogy Forum UK

This is confusing who is he?

On the 1851 as shown below he is with wife Elizabeth
Possible marriage
1850 WITHERS Henry HODGKINS Elizabeth Dudley, St Thomas Dudley Register Office 204/010/74

Now it isnt Henry son of John Withers as that Henry marries Mary Parsons and is with her on 51 and 61 and
marriage for them checks out


1851: Gaunts Fold, Halesowen
John Withers 54 Head Sawyer b. Rowley, Staffs
Ann Withers 54 Wife b.H/Owen, Worc
Chas Withers 18 Son U b.Lye,Worc
Marianne Withers 14 Dau Nailer b.Lye,Worc

Next Door on 1851 :

Henry Withers 24 Head Lab
Elizth Withers 24 Wife
Ellen Withers 6 Dau
Henry Withers 4 Son
all born in County

who is he??

Northern Lass wrote:

peterd wrote:1861 Hagley Rd, Halesowen

Henry Withers 36 Labourer Waggoner
Elizabeth Withers 35
Ellen Withers 15 ?maker Apprentice
Henry Withers 14

all born Halesowen

1851 Gaunts Fold HAlesowen
Henry Withers 24 Head Lab
Elizth Withers 24 Wife
Ellen Withers 6 Dau
Henry Withers 4 Son
all born in County

1841 Cornbow Street Halesowen
Thomas Withers 40 Timber Dealer not born in county
Sophia Withers 35
Thomas Withers 15 Sawyer
Henry Withers 12
Ellen Withers 9

Next door John Withers 20 Sawyer

Sister Ellen - name repeat!

So Thomas looks like father of that Henry and John Withers could be brother to Thomas?

http://bcconnections.tribalpages.com/tr ... onnections

maybe? or not?

An Ancestry tree has ...
John Withers (1772 Halesowen) m. Elizabeth Bache (1771) on 22 May 1796
Children:
John 1797 - 1871
Thomas 1800 - 1870
Joseph 1802 - 1857
Edward 1805 - 1892 *
Henry 1809 - 1884
Charles 1812 - 1890
William 1815 - 1855
Elizabeth 1819 - 1821
Elizabeth 1821

ok sorted that henry is bro to thomas and John so
John has his nephew next to him in 1851

completed