Phebe and Ann Harper are they sisters

[Northern Lass]

Can anyone see this pair on earlier census pls

think they may be sisters....but no proof

Ann Harper here
http://bcconnections.tribalpages.com/tr ... =539075240

and Phebe Harper here
http://bcconnections.tribalpages.com/tr ... =270905693

[Jimmy]

1861. New Rd, Cradley.
Benjamin Harper 40. Labourer in iron works. Clent, Worcs.
Mary A Harper 24. Cradley.
Ann Harper 2. Cradley.

West Midlands Marriage indexes for the years: 1854.
HARPER Benjamin. BUTLER Mary A. Dudley, St Thomas. Dudley Register Office. 204/014/107.

[Northern Lass]

Thanks Jimmy that could be her

poss for Ann in 1871 so is Mary Ann her mother?

1871 Corngreaves Road, Rowley Regis, Dudley, Staffordshire, England
Samuel Butler Head - Male 29 1842 - Worcestershire
Fanny Butler Wife - Female 44 1827 - Worcestershire
Matilda Butler Daughter - Female 17 1854 - Worcestershire
Joseph Butler Son - Male 15 1856 - Worcestershire
Emma Butler Daughter - Female 12 1859 - Worcestershire
Eli Butler Son - Male 10 1861 - Worcestershire
Enoch Butler Son - Male 4 1867 - Worcestershire
Saml Butler Son - Male 3 1868 - Worcestershire
Mary Ann Harper Niece - Female 34 1837 - Worcestershire
Ann Harper Daughter - Female 12 1859 - Staffordshire
Benj Harper Son - Male 6 1865 - Staffordshire

where is Phebe harper then?.....maybe phebe is a cousin?

[Northern Lass]

we cant find a marriage for Benjamin Clee and Ann Harper.......we have looked

[Jimmy]

looks like it to me, but I can't see a Phoebe and Ann together.

[Northern Lass]

1861. New Rd, Cradley.
Benjamin Harper 40. Labourer in iron works. Clent, Worcs.
Mary A Harper 24. Cradley.
Ann Harper 2. Cradley.

West Midlands Marriage indexes for the years: 1854.
HARPER Benjamin. BUTLER Mary A. Dudley, St Thomas. Dudley Register Office. 204/014/107.

I think that looks good
we have them here going to connect up
http://bcconnections.tribalpages.com/tr ... =746462367

[Northern Lass]

can anyone find a marriage for Benjamin Clee and a Harper.....any spelling?

[Jimmy]

Its Clee on image.
1881. 11 Mill St, Cradley.
Benjimin Clus 25. Chainmaker.
Ann Harper 23. Boarder unm. Cradley.
Thomas Davies 32.
Jane Davies 9.
Joseph Davies 8.
Mariah Davies 5.

Others are boarders

[Jimmy]

can anyone find a marriage for Benjamin Clee and a Harper.....any spelling?

I can't.

[Jimmy]

Its Clee on image.
1881. 11 Mill St, Cradley.
Benjimin Clus 25. Chainmaker.
Ann Harper 23. Boarder unm. Cradley.
Thomas Davies 32.
Jane Davies 9.
Joseph Davies 8.
Mariah Davies 5.

Others are boarders

It states on the image that Benjamin Clee is married.

[sparkstopper]

can anyone find a marriage for Benjamin Clee and a Harper.....any spelling?

There's a: Benjamin CLLE marr: Maria NOTT or Ann POWELL
1871 Kidderminster. Apr/June ...6C 347. on FMP.
NOT on WMBMD....prob. bit early for our Benj:

[Jimmy]

I now of the one in Kidder, it was Ann Powell they connect to me and lived in Kidder.

[Northern Lass]

So do you have the marriage info Jimmy?

and we discount it do we as our Ann......it seems she is deffo a Harper

wot we think?

[Jimmy]

I have some where but it is not the same couple.